Here are municipal tax rates for 2014 within Durham Region. I have included Toronto and other places, as many of my clients express frustration at the higher taxes that Durham residents face when compared to the rest of the GTA.
If you look at the average property in each city, the difference in assessed values for similar properties actually make our area less expensive on municipal taxes than in Toronto.
Understanding the municipal tax process
First, we need to understand that our municipal governments have to provide similar services, regardless of how much our properties are worth. In virtually all budgets, the number one expense is for the salaries of public employees - police, fire, EMS, municipal workers, road maintenance, etc. Those people make roughly the same amount from one community to the next.
In those cities with higher average property values, they can apply a lower tax rate to come up with a similar amount of revenue. Of course, there will be differences based on population size and other factors, but you get the idea.
Without delving too much into the process, they establish a budget, and determine from that how much revenue needs to come from property taxes. They then adjust what is called the millage (or mill) rate of each property type to come up with the amount needed to reach the revenue target.
Changes to the assessment value and rate each year are designed to be revenue-neutral. This means that when your MPAC assessment increases, it will be multiplied by a lower tax rate to come up with the same amount of tax. Of course, this assumes that you haven't made any material change to your property, and also that the municipality hasn't increased it's budget. Budgets do increase, for inflation and changes in service levels.
Toronto vs. Oshawa Taxes
For example, the City of Toronto has one of the lowest rates in the province. That may sound wonderful, but when you take into account that it also has one of the highest property assessment averages, the actual amount of municipal tax you pay there isn't much different than in other places. For example, the average price for a single detached home sold in October, 2014 was $951,746 in Toronto, and in Oshawa, it was $338,923.
- Toronto $951,746 times 0.723% or $6,881.20
- Oshawa $338,923 times 1.591% or $5,391.15
On an average property, Oshawa's taxpayers pay 21% less than in Toronto!
Of course, these figures only represent averages. On higher-end properties, the rates will have a bigger impact. The rates are different for different property types, and there are many variations of classes in commercial and industrial properties. If you have a question regarding another type, or another municipality in the area, you can contact me and I would be happy to explain further.